16th May 2008

Nissan goes Porsche-bashing with cracking GT-R

Last week I got to so spend some time with the chief engineer of the Nissan GT-R, Kazutoshi Mizuno. He’s clearly a proud bloke, and rightfully so.

After all he’s been in charge of the program to bring back one of the most eagerly anticipated sports cars in years.

The Nissan GT-R is a cult car that’s admired the world over, but particularly in Australia where the R32 model dominated the local motor racing scene almost 20 years ago. It was so good it was effectively banned as the rulemakers reverted to a V8-only formula, ousting the twin-turbocharged six-cylinder all-wheel-drive that was nicknamed Godzilla.

The new GT-R is a cracker, something I experienced with three laps to really test it at the Estoril race track in Portugal.

There’s 358kW and 582Nm from the 3.8-litre, twin turbocharged V6, which is nothing to be sneezed at. The GT-R is supremely quick - and does it so easily.

Outright acceleration isn’t quite as brutal as the new Porsche 911 GT2, which has incredible mid-range urge thanks to its prodigious torque delivery.

But the GT-R compensates with all-wheel-drive traction (the 911 GT2 – the fastest Porsche on the market – drives only the rear wheels and can struggle for grip in lower gears due to the immense grunt of the twin-turbo engine). Its double clutch semi-automatic gearbox also punches through the gears extremely quickly helping shave precious tenths of a second off acceleration times.

The all-wheel-drive system does a brilliant job of clawing what is a reasonably heavy car (1.7 tonnes) out of corners, while still allowing keener drivers to slide the rear-end with the sort of controllability cars like this need.

The Brembo brakes bite hard, although the three hot laps were enough to leave the fronts smoking by the time I arrived back in the pits (Nissan was replacing the brake pads every day of the test drive program and each car was doing about 70 laps a day).

The result is an extremely capable and potently fast car. Plus it has a character of its own – the digital display brings a little bit of computer game to the dash, for example.

Still, there’s little doubt the GT-R is one of those cars that needs a race track to fully appreciate its potential.

And it’s a race track where the GT-R recently earned its best accolade – a scorching lap time around the Nurburgring race track in Germany. The 21-kilometre undulating track is used by car makers all over the world for testing and development and as a benchmark of performance.

The GT-R’s 7 minute, 29 second time is quicker than any production Porsche sold here, something Nissan is – understandably – eager to point out.

There are already mutterings that some think Nissan went to extreme lengths to achieve the blistering time. And they did.

Then again, the likes of Porsche has renowned test driver – and former world rally champion – Walter Rohrl.

In 2007 Nissan set a time of 7 minutes, 38 seconds in 2007 in the GT-R at Nurburgring, but Mizuno says two parts of the track were wet. Hence the second attempt to better that time.

Mizuno is also adamant the time was achieved in exactly the same car customers will be able to buy, right down to the road legal Bridgestone tyres. The passionate chief engineer even showed journalists detailed data, overlaying the data from the 2007 run with the data for the 2008 run.

There’s little doubt Porsche will have a tilt at beating the GT-R benchmark, be it in one of their existing cars or an upcoming car (the updated 911 isn’t far away). Then again, the marketing message doesn’t work quite as well for Porsche because people expect a Porsche to beat a Nissan.

Toby Hagon

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

New Porsche 4×4 in pipeline

Porsche is planning to increase its model line-up to five with a new mini-4×4 called the Roxster.

The compact SUV was photographed leaving the firm’s HQ in Stuttgart and it appears Porsche wants to produce an-offroader that will take on the BMW X3 and other compact 4×4s.

It follows the success of Cayenne and will be built in partnership with Volkswagen.

The new Roxster is likely to include components from Audi’s all-new Q5 and it could be the first Porsche to feature a diesel powerplant.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

Aussie firm on night racing for Formula One

Plans for a Formula One night race at Albert Park have sparked a drive to the front of sports lighting.

Hella Australia has developed an innovative trackside illumination system that is being pitched for grand prix work, but could revolutionise night coverage of a wide range of sports.

The reflector system is said to be safe, immune to blackouts, shadow-free and compatible for live TV coverage.

Hella ran a secret test at Calder Park Raceway on November 12, which involved Red Bull F1 driver Mark Webber and former world motorcycle champion Mick Doohan.

It has submitted the results to world motorsport governing body, FIA, for certification of its system.

“We have shown it can be done. That is the most important thing,” Hella Australia spokesman Thomas Plessinger said yesterday.

Plessinger is in Europe for a series of meetings involving FIA and other potential F1 opportunities.

“A year ago it was a dream, but now we know it’s realistic. We are submitting our technical measurements and television footage to the FIA and Formula One management and we are waiting for their response,” Plessinger said.

The multi-million-dollar development program began at Hella’s technical centre in Mentone earlier this year, following serious talks about night grands prix in the Asia-Pacific region. Night races could be broadcast live into Europe in the morning.

Australian Grand Prix organisers have already moved the starting time for next year’s race back to the late afternoon, while the inaugural Singapore Grand Prix on September 28 will be a full-scale night race under lights.

There is still talk of a night race at Albert Park in the future.

More than 50 engineers were involved in the work as Hella created its system and build 44 trial units, including a generator, supports and lighting unit, for the Calder trial.

“We spoke to the FIA in August in Hungary and we agreed on a demonstration. We had a light sample which we had already tested in Melbourne as a proof of concept,” Plessinger said.

“For the trial we had 44 units. The requirement from the FIA was to light 500 metres, so we did a straight, a fast corner and a slow corner.”

Plessinger said the Hella trial followed a trial at Indianapolis by American company Musco, which has provided lighting systems for a number of motorsport operations, including the Calder Park Raceway.

The company is looking to mass produce its system and is scouting a range of business opportunities, although it had not pitched for the planned Qatar MotoGP race, to be run under lights in the Middle East next year.

“Our system is designed, developed and manufactured in Australia. It is possible that we can light all motorsport, even as far as Formula One,” Plessinger said.

“There are opportunities for other sports. Any application is suitable for our lights, but Formula One is the pinnacle.”

- Herald Sun

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

Radical Cube is on ice, for now

Square world: the Nissan Cube, Japan’s most successful city car and a hit with younger drivers.

Nissan’s radical city car is there if Australia has the market

The most successful of Japan’s boxy Gen-Y city cars, the Nissan Cube, is finally firming for Australia.

The compact Cube was previously rejected as too radical and too expensive for local buyers, but things could change — and fast — after a European preview last week.

Nissan Australia now believes there could be a place for the car — and it could give the company an edge against Toyota, which is still struggling to find a Gen-Y niche for Australia.

“It’s an interesting car that would give us a unique proposition for Gen-Y. It’s something I believe is lacking in the Australian market,” says Ross Booth, the new general manager of marketing at Nissan Australia.

The Cube has an 80kW 1.5-litre engine, fuel consumption of 5.15 litres/km and a CVT automatic gearbox. Its boxy body has two rows of folding bench seats.

Japan’s twentysomethings love it and customise it to their individual preferences.

Booth has been won over by the car. But he knows it will not be a straightforward sell to Australian customers or to Japanese management.

To succeed, he says the car needs to be priced right and sell in enough volume to fund a proper launch.

“It’s the business equation of volume and price to do the job.”

But he sounds a warning on the likely price, which will be much higher than Nissan’s current Micra price leader at $14,990.

“It’s going to be closer to $30,000 than $20,000. Will Generation Y fork out that amount to be different?” Booth asks.

He says final decisions will have to wait for the next-generation Cube, probably next year.

The Cube has been a top-10 seller in Japan since 2003, but its appeal to Gen-Y is the reason Nissan wants it to get an edge on Toyota.

Toyota has had nothing like the Cube since it canned its Daihatsu division in Australia, though it has created an all-new Scion brand in the US to lure younger buyers.

“Scion works in the US, but would it work in Australia? We don’t know,” Booth says. “And we’d have to establish the market.”

 


Do you agree the Cube is the car for Aussie Gen-Y? Have your say below.


 

 

- The Daily Telegraph

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

The Truth About The Truth About The Truth About Cars’ Take About Newspaper Car Reviews

By Robert Farago
May 15, 2008 - 582 Views

This “article” by Sam Moses appeared on an newsletter/website called autowriters.com, an Inside Baseball-type publication for automotive journalists. When I read the not-so-divine Mr. M’s diatribe, I was more than slightly miffed. His rant completely misrepresents Frank Williams’ editorial on automotive reviews in newspapers. So I called autowriter.com’s main main, Glenn F. Campbell. I asked the publisher point blank if he’d actually read Frank’s article. Nope. But that was O.K. because it’s OK to publish someone’s opinion, even if it is factually inaccurate or, in this case, devoid of factual justification. When I reminded Campbell that he’s legally liable for libel (just to tweak his nose), Campbell didn’t get it. “You said there were no facts cited so what could I check  - to see if my opinions agree with Sam’s? Homogenous opinions would make a dull, narrow-minded Newsletter.” And yet, that’s what he’s created. I’ve calmed down enough to see the unintentional humor of Mr. Moses’ TTAC attack. Still, I think it’s important for our readers to contemplate the full glory of what we’re up against, day in, day out.  

Click here for
The Truth About The Truth About Cars’ Take
on The Truth About Newspaper Car Reviews

 

20 Responses to “
The Truth About The Truth About The Truth About Cars’ Take About Newspaper Car Reviews ”

Pages: [1] 2 Âť Show All Reverse Order

  • Robert Farago :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    10:41 pm

    Two important facts:

    1. “He says that to get information from an engineer is a sign of bias.” He does not.

    2. “We at TTAC are too weak to filter out the manufacturers’ spin at launches, and not smart enough to find the good technical information that’s all over the place. So we don’t go to them.” TTAC attends new product launches and other manufacturer-sponsored events– when invited (obviously). We always list any and all manufacturers’ contributions to an article (transportation, lodging, food, gas, insurance, etc.)

  • Justin Berkowitz :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:14 pm

    Declarative sentences. For the consumer. Dry, yes; that’s the price of the pursuit of truth—and I’m not saying it’s always there, either.

    Okay, two problems here.

    The first is that Moses assumes all automotive review readers are the same.

    Second, why must pursuit of the truth be dry? Ever heard the expression “It’s funny because it’s true”?

  • David Holzman :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:23 pm

    One thing Moses is blatantly ignorant of is the fact that TTAC is not aimed at the consumer. But Moses’ diatribe is so disorganized and badly written that I wouldn’t have gotten past the first couple of sentences if I had come across this anywhere but on TTAC. I had to read it several times to figure out what he was trying to say. It is worse than amateurish. My advice to RF is to take this item down and forget about it. Its inconsequential IMO.

  • Robert Farago :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:23 pm

    Justin Berkowitz:

    Declarative sentences.

    Is not. A sentence.

  • dean :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:23 pm

    As if a 4-hour exclusive interview with an engineer or product or PR person could somehow HURT a review.

    If I spent four hours with a friendly engineer/designer while caning the snot out of his pride and joy, I might have trouble telling the world that he couldn’t design his way out of a paper bag. Not that this would happen, but that is how it could hurt a review.

    And he needn’t worry about TTAC’s ability to sort the spin from reality. The whole point of Frank’s editorial was that the typical newspaper car reviewer doesn’t bother.

    Like you said RF, it was pretty obvious the guy didn’t do more than skim the piece at best.

  • Richard Chen :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:25 pm

    Sam Moses writes for (among many other things) newcartestdrive.com whose staff includes other members of established automotive news media, but whose Alexa rating which at 1/5th of TTAC’s could use a little boost. It is owned by Internet Brands, which owns CarsDirect.com, AutoData.net, Autos.com (best mid-sized car: Buick Lacrosse, hmm), a whole bucketload of car forums I’ve never stumbled upon, wikicars.org, and many other sides not automotive. Not that it makes any difference, but their Board of Directors has this fellow named Roger Penske.

    David’s slingshot is at the ready, fire at will.

  • Jordan Tenenbaum :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:25 pm

    It’s people like him who help reiterate why I come here.

  • sean362880 :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:35 pm

    Methinks Sam dost protest too much. TTAC readers are not average consumers; they are much more knowledgeable about cars and discerning about automotive writing than newspaper readers (on average). Frankly, we don’t need dry technical information because we already know it. We WANT subjective opinion, because car buying is such a personal and emotional choice.

  • sightline :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:39 pm

    You could fill many issues of autowriters.com with examples of horrible, inaccurate TTAC autojournalism that he thinks is clever and truthful—and I’d cite them if there were room here.

    This is the worst kind of writing, engaging in a petty little ad-hom remark then refusing to back it up. This indicates either an unwillingness to read TTAC’s reviews or an inability to find support for this statement. The writer threw this rhetorical device onto the page, hoping that the reader would just casually nod and continue on.

    I’d expect such a thing on the playground, but not in anything written by a putative professional.

  • steronz :


    May 15th, 2008 at
    11:45 pm

    RF:

    How does “[BTW: Keane also mentions that a Chrysler engineer accompanied him on the test drive. Nope. No bias shown there.]” (Frank’s words) all that different from “He says that to get information from an engineer is a sign of bias?” I mean, you’re splitting hairs and arguing semantics if you say that’s not what Frank was suggesting.

    I tend to agree with TTAC’s stance that any test drives should ideally be conducted in a production vehicle without the knowledge or consent of the manufacturer, much like Consumer Reports. However, I can see this guy’s point. I don’t agree with it, but I can see it.

    And frankly, I don’t think it’s that inflammatory. When I saw that you were all worked up over an article earlier today, I figured it would be something really bad. Now that I’ve read it, I’m thinking TTAC just has thin skin.

Pages: [1] 2 Âť Show All Reverse Order

Leave a Reply Back to Top

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

Noble M600 Prototype Z1 ready to be announced

In a recent interview with Piston Heads, the company’s new boss Peter Boutwood announced that the launch of the new M600 is near by. The car will be conceptually similar to a Ferrari F40 and will be limited to only 40 unit a year.

The car is currently under testings and development programme. The M600 is to be announced, but this will not happen before it has been completely and thoroughly tested.

It will however be a carbon fibre body shell, twin turbo V8 powered, with a six speed gearbox designed and developed for Noble by Graziano Trasmissioni.

The M600 will have no “absolute” competitors, but obviously it will appeal to those already in the high performance market; the nearest competitor Noble can equate in conceptual terms is probably the Ferrari F40.

The car will not have a convertible version and Noble will soon post the first images on its official web site.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

JDM Goodness: Subaru Legacy STI S402


Click above for a high-res gallery of the Subaru Legacy STI S402.

Subaru is taunting us again with yet another limited-edition model that we’ll likely never see Stateside. The Legacy STI S402 will be limited to (appropriately) 402 units in both sedan and wagon trim, featuring the STI’s turbocharged, 2.5-liter flat-four. Unlike some of the other “special” Subies, the S402 Legacy means business. To begin with, the front fenders have been widened by 20mm, the steering ratio has been reduced to 13:1 and Bilstein shocks are fitted at all four corners, along with 18-inch BBS wheels wrapped in Bridgestone Potenza RE050A rubber. The brakes have been upgraded to units from Brembo, with six-piston calipers up front and two-pot calipers in the rear gripping upgraded rotors. Aside from all the required badging, Subaru has fitted new gauges to the IP, along with a MOMO steering wheel and aluminum shift knob.

Sales begin in Japan on June 27th, with prices starting ÂĽ5,491,500 for the wagon and ÂĽ5,355,000 for the sedan. We’ll take one of each, thank you very much.

[Source: Subaru]

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

Cross Country in a Mini, Route 66 history along the way

Some people consider traveling cross-country a bore, while others consider following the roads that keep our nation moving quite an adventure. I’m one of those adventurous types who see beyond the miles of flat asphalt that litter our hillsides and desert plains. Route 66, which connects the East and West, is arguably the most famous stretch of highway in U.S. history. Many have traveled its winding roads, and much of the original road has been torn up and rerouted as part of the newer Interstate 40.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

GM, Chrysler reach CAW deals

The Canadian Auto Workers has tentative labor pacts with General Motors Corp. and Chrysler LLC, the union said today.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments

16th May 2008

ANE boosts sales team

Saremba, 33, takes over from Nina Sauer, who earlier this year became ANE’s sales and marketing director.

Read more

posted in Car News Articles | 0 Comments